home | about us | contact | site map | credits | disclaimer | bookmark

Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority: a governmental regulatory body which is worthless and ineffectual


Sunday, June 01, 2008

Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority: a governmental regulatory body which is worthless and ineffectual


The Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority is the governmental body whose job it is to oversee and regulate all gambling operations located in Malta. The 2004 Remote Gaming Legislation lays out the requirements, and it includes the following heartening clause:


The Authority may order the suspension or cancellation of a license if...the license holder has failed to meet commitments to players


Unfortunately, the reality does not match the marketing. The Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority does not, in fact, do anything for players who lodge complaints with them regarding their licensees.


On the 3rd of March 2008 I lodged a complaint with the Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority, regarding confiscation of over £5000 in winnings on the part of Interwetten sportsbook and casino - see my Interwetten confiscation of more than £5000 article.

Mario Galea, the CEO of the Malta LGA, to whom I complained, acknowledged receipt of my email and said he would pass it on to the player support manager.

As of 1st of June 2008, three months later, I have heard nothing.

A handful of other players had identical problems, and they complained at Casinomeister - see the Interwetten confiscating winnings thread.

All these players also lodged complaints. None of them have heard anything.

However, the Malta LGA did deign to issue one communication, to "Casinomeister" Bryan Bailey, an unaffected third party. Bailey reported thus:


The LGA said that Interwetten had paid a number of the affected players, but had specific reasons not to pay the others.


Apparently, this is an "investigation" according to the Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority:

• They do not acknowledge receipt of anything from anyone.

• They do not communicate in any way with players who lodge complaints.

• They communicate with third parties, who have no business knowing any details in the first place, that their findings are that "the casino had reasons not to pay".

• They offer no rebuttal options.

• They offer no explanations.

In fact, The Malta LGA says nothing beyond that which the players didn't already know anyway, ie. that the casino was confiscating their money. This is the sum total of their "investigation".

Is this the end of the story of the somewhat spectacularly failed Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority?

No.


For the past few months, another Maltese-licensed operation, Betchance, has been in no-pay mode, and currently owes players somewhere in the region of $100,000. Here are some summaries from Sportsbook Review:


1/22/2008 11:06 PM

First BetChance (SBR rating F) payout activity observed in nearly five months

Two players confirmed receiving payouts less than $500 USD. The book sent the following message prior to payment:

"Thanks for your collaboration and support during these months. Betchance would like to inform you that your withdrawal has been processed. Also note that all the company's problems have been solved. Within few weeks we will offer new offers and services through our website. You are welcome, to visit betchance.com!"

Players should avoid being optimistic until more substantial withdrawals are issued. This message was similar to what the book sent with very small payouts last September. The sportsbook owes over $100,000 to SBR readers alone. These two payments were made via bank wire.




2/5/2008 08:39 AM

BetChance (SBR rating F) player confirms 2480 EUR paid. This marks the largest payout reported of a total amount just above $4000USD since the book first stopped processing payouts in September.

Delinquent withdrawal requests remain over $100,000.



5/1/2008 08:33 PM

BetChance (SBR rating D-) scam continues after scattered payouts
Many players who filed a complaint reported payment at the start of April. BetChance failed to pay players at the close of 2007 and beginning of this year. The sportsbook was upgraded from F to D- in April to reflect the possibility of payment. Players have since wrote to SBR strongly objecting to the sportsbook having a rating above F-. BetChance payouts have not continued while its marketing campaign has. BetChance is telling players they are only able to withdraw the amount they deposited. The result is new players depositing in an effort to win money the book will not pay.

Player to BetChance: "I am still waiting on a response to my email from 31st January 2008 (10 weeks ago !!!). Furthermore there are 5 open withdrawals over 5000 Euro in total. Please let me know within 7 days when you will payout this amount. Please regard that sportsbookreview.com has changed your rating from F to D- on 7th April and I think that you won't be pleased if your rating will changed again to F."


Betchance owes a minimum of $100,000, and as such has the absolute worst rating at Sportsbook Review, an F-, reserved for the biggest and worst sportsbook scams on the internet.

The Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority lists Betchance among its licensees - see the Authorised Remote Gaming Operators page, under the "class 2" listings. The LGA has not removed Betchance's license, in spite of this sportsbook's spectacular failure to "meet commitments to players" as per the terms of the 2004 Remote Gaming Act.


So, in summary:

• When players complain to the Malta LGA, they are completely ignored.

• When LGA licensees stop paying players and end up owing large sums of money, with no apparent prospect of payment, the LGA happily continues to allow them to maintain their license.


Any casino or sportsbook operator considering relocation to Malta as an ostensibly "reputable" jurisdiction should bear in mind the following:

1) That the Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority has no credibility with the player community, and as such, operations within the jurisdiction of Malta will not be considered safe by such players who will then not give Malta licensees their business. This has obvious financial consequences: fewer players equates to less money.

2) That gambling regulation within the European Union has gained pace recently, acting as some counterbalance to the action taken against online gambling by the United States in 2006 with the passing of the Internet Gambling Prohibition And Enforcement Act. For gambling regulators to now be seen to be spectacularly failing is possibly the very worst thing for the online gambling industry at his moment.


Players and industry mover & shakers be warned: the Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority is an ineffectual, worthless and dangerous blot on the copybook of the European online gambling regulatory scene.

***Update Monday June 2nd 2008***

Less than twelve hours after writing the above article, lo and behold I received my first communication from the Malta LGA, to the effect that my emails have been received and the matter is being investigated. How this squares with the LGA's statement to a webmaster that Interwetten had "valid reasons not to pay" I cannot begin to imagine. However, I'm glad to have finally received the courtesy of a response.



5 Previous Comments


Great thanks for your article.

I also have problem with betchance and I win over £20k in betchance. However I didnt receive my money.

I have been contact with this bookie for almost 1 year, what I have got is rubish promise.

Is any way to solve the

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 7:25 pm  


have you contacted the SBR people?

http://www.sportsbookreview.com/Sportsbook+Complaint.aspx

Also, a post on their forum might get you up to speed with other issues and some general support:

http://forum.sbrforum.com/players-talk/

Of course, you should "officially" make a complaint to the LGA, but we know that is a complete waste of time. It wouldn't hurt to do it anyway, just for form's sake.

By Blogger 100% Gambler, at 2:36 pm  


good article - having you tried contacting the racing post to see if they have any interest in exposting the farce that is the LGA

it must be worth a try

i am another punter owed money by betchance - i have found the lga to be as useless as your article suggests

i have also contacted the maltese ministry of finance who regulate the lga, suprise suprise they are just as useless

this is a scandal and needs exposing

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:16 pm  


Would this be something of interest to The Racing Post? I'm not much familiar with it, but it seems UK track racing fucussed. I'm not sure if governmental departments in far-flung European outposts would be much of interest to them.

Unsurprisingly, I have heard not a word further from the Malta Lotteries And Gaming Authority. I have told them they will be seeing me at next year's ICE and that I'll certainly be seeking legal recourse against them in Malta.

They simply do not respond.

By Blogger 100% Gambler, at 11:15 pm  


I've done another writeup for Midas Oracle.

By Blogger 100% Gambler, at 4:39 pm  


Post a Comment


May 2005 | June 2005 | July 2005 | September 2005 | October 2005 | November 2005 | December 2005 | January 2006 | February 2006 | March 2006 | April 2006 | May 2006 | August 2006 | October 2006 | January 2007 | February 2007 | March 2007 | May 2007 | June 2007 | July 2007 | January 2008 | February 2008 | March 2008 | April 2008 | June 2008 | July 2008 | September 2008 | October 2008 | December 2008 | January 2009 | February 2009 | March 2009 | May 2009 | June 2009 | July 2009 | August 2009 | September 2009 | October 2009 | November 2009 | December 2009 | January 2010 | February 2010 | March 2010 | April 2010 | May 2010 | June 2010 | July 2010 | August 2010 | October 2010 | November 2010 | December 2010 | January 2011 | February 2011 | March 2011 | April 2011 | May 2011 | June 2011 | July 2011 | August 2011 | September 2011 | December 2011 | February 2012 | May 2012 | July 2012 | August 2012 | March 2016 | April 2016 | June 2016 | November 2016 | December 2016 | March 2017 | May 2017 | June 2017 | August 2017 | Atom feed
© 2005 hundred percent gambling

ONLINE CASINO NEWS

• Online casino news


2016

• Can't split 10s?
• Overbetting
• EV charts
• The IPCA
• Basic strategy master
• Back to the future
• Site hack

2015

• Better comp value
• Pit bosses are a pest
• 32Red buys Roxy Palace
• Winneronline is gone
• Paradise Win Casino
• Blackjack simple strategy

2014

• Court refuses Ivey winnings
• Phil Ivey versus Crockfords
• 32Red does the right thing
• Wizard Of Odds sold
• Gambling addict sues Ritz
• Better blackjack conditions
• FL: the beat goes on
• Phil Ivey and the Borgata
• LadbrokesFOBT profit
• Chat with the Met
• "Bonus abuse" and the Met
• Casino industry crooks.
• Debate to curb the FOBTs
• Labour idea to ban FOBTs

2013

• Ruby Fortune: terms buried
• Royal Vegas: bad outcome
• Russia illegalises gambling
• RV: player breaks no rules
• Gib casinos and UK laws
• The GGC (GRA) useless
• BetFred rigged games 9
• BetFred rigged games 8
• Betfred rigged games 7
• BetFred rigged games 6
• BetFred rigged games 5
• BetFred rigged games 4
• Phil Ivey: is he entitled?
• BetFred rigged games 3
• Betfred rigged games 2
• BetFred: rigged games 1
•  UK GLA Act 2013
• 888.com and Facebook
• Crockfords denies Phil Ivey
• Bad dealers
• Betfair Blackjack test
• Playtech software update
• Cheap blackjack
• Hippodrome Casino

2012

• The UK's FOBT addiction
• Conan Casino beware
• Intercasino misleading
• Fortune Lounge
• UK Gambling Commission

2011

• Small Claims Court
• Gamcare
• Full Tilt Poker saved
• Full Tilt ponzi scheme
• Casino Barcelona
• Irakli Kacharava
• Betfair processor no pay
• Full Tilt licensing meeting
• UK Gambling Commission
• Full Tilt Poker investors
• Full Tilt license suspended
• Twitter
• Betfair resolution
• Casino Web Scripts 2
• 32Red bonus marketing
• Casino Web Scripts 1
• Poker domains seized
• eCOGRA independent?
• Easystreet Sports theft
• Betfair to Gibraltar
• Rigged blackjack 2
• Betfair responses
• Rigged blackjack
• 888.com theft
• Betfair poker problem
• UK gambling controls
• Harry Reid

2010

• eWallet Xpress
• Kevin Stillmock
• Blog back up
• Betfair happy hour
• Ladbrokes bonus increase
• Absolute Poker tricks US
• Absolute Poker rigged
• Last position no difference
• Basic strategy simplified
• Online casino bonuses
• Righthaven LLC
• Ladbrokes bonus rules
• Malta LGA nonsense
• Purple Lounge theft
• UK affiliates issue
• Online casino problems
• GPWA code of conduct
• One Club Casino problems
• Rushmore theft resolved
• Realtime Gaming cheats
• Absolute Poker Ultimate Bet
• Rushmore Casino theft
• Ask gamblers service
• Intercasino bonus terms
• Profitting from poverty
• Gambling dooms UK to ruin
• Want To Stop Gambling
• Gambling Therapy
• Gordon Moody Association
• Breakeven
• Online gambling jobs
• Gamblock
• Gamble Aware
• Gamblers Anonymous
• Gamcare
• Video poker auto hold
• Gambling Wages help offer
• Blackjack double down
• Intercasino rules
• Tradition Casino warning
• Tradition Casino problem
• Be The Dealer
• eCOGRA approved casinos
• UK underage gambling
• iGaming Super Show
• eCOGRA reputable portals
• eCOGRA exposed
• Slots Oasis warning
• Slots Oasis problem
• HR 2267 comments
• HR 2267 proposed bill
• Search fully functional
• Gambling hearing delayed
• Betfair download blackjack
• Betfair blackjack
• The Federal Wie Act
• Casino Rewards warning
• Kahnawake dumps GP
• GP dumps Microgaming
• UK online gambling
• Gambling checklist
• Online casino problems
• Gambling Grumbles
• Casino Rewards
• Brian Cullingworth
• Casino Wager Tracker
• Grand Prive affiliates
• Jackpots Heaven Casino
• Kahnawake commission
• UK gambling problem
• eCOGRA and Grand Prive
• Bet365 misleading bonus
• Mastercard and Visa
• Online gambling rules
• 32Red sign up bonus
• Ladbrokes data theft
• Ladbrokes unfair settlement
• Palace group bonus rules
• Grand Prive and eCOGRA

2009

• Blackjack in the UK
• Seminole Hard Rock
• The APCW and MG
• Sportsbook.com
• Slot beaters slot strategy
• Rushmore Casino theft
• Paddy Power affiliates
• Slots
• 888.com problem
• The UIGEA
• Neteller contest winner
• 888.com bonus problem
• Casino Club meeting
• Online casino directory
• 32Red debit card bonus
• Blue Square Casino
• Budapest Affiliate Expo
• Rushmore payment issues
• Modern Blackjack volume 1
• Eurolinx certain insolvency
• Buzzluck winnings theft
• PaddyPower removed
• 32Red lawsuit
• William Hill Casino Club
• Betfair video poker
• APCW underage children
• Odds page updates
• VP Genius
• Video poker page updates
• Blackjack page updates
• Progression page updates
• Single deck page updates
• Betfair Playtech license
• Cherry Red Casino
• Online gambling debate
• William Hill & Teddy Sagi
• Rogue casinos section
• Pontoon correction
• Microgaming poker scandal
• Casino Club confiscation
• Casino Club steals €8000
• Villa Fortuna Casino
• Grand Prive affiliate issue
• CAP and Cardspike 2
• Virgin Casino bad results
• CAP and Cardspike 1

2008

• iNetbet removal from site
• Mario Galea and Malta LGA
• Cold Mountain Resort
• The AGCC
• Moneybookers privacy
• Virtual Casino rebranding
• Captain Jack Casino
• Royal Ace Casino
• Ringmaster Casino
• Catseye Casino
• Lucky Palm Casino
• Pharaohs Gold Casino
• Goldstream Casino
• Plantet 7 Casino
• Betfair bonus confiscation
• Malta LGA worthless
• The GIA
• Interwetten theft of £5000
• Lucky Ace winnings stolen
• The KGC and Absolute

2007

• HippoJo Casino
• Microgaming All Aces VP
• Neteller issues
• Lou Fabiano responds
• Lou Fabiano selling stats
• Betfair Zero Lounge
• ICE 2007 brief visit
• RTG cancels ICE visit

2006

• Crystal Palace Casino theft
• eCOGRA & Jackpot Factory
• English Harbour cheating
• Boss Media single deck
• Bella Vegas / Grand Prive
• The KGC worthless
• Gambling Federation
• Playtech sued
• Meeting Andrew Beveridge
• Playtech confirmed listing
• African Palace Casino
• G-Fed ICE discussion
• Playtech ICE meeting
• Playtech issues escalation
• Chartwell hands off

2005

• Crystal Gaming silence
• Price Waterhouse Cooper
• Crystal Gaming flotation 2
• Vegas Frontier
• Crystal Gaming flotation 1
• Playtech public listing
• African Palace & Indio
• Kiwi Casino
• Rochester Casino
• G-Fed theft 2
• Warren Cloud best avoided
• Golden Palace stupidity 3
• Golden Palace stupidity 2
• G-Fed theft 1
• Golden Palace stupidity 1
• Russia online expansion
• Wan Doy Pairs Poker
• Microgaming CPU usage
• Net Entertainment RNG
• Cryptologic & William Hill
• Casino growth slow
• English Harbour paying
• Fraudster or not
• Blackjack surrender
• Integrity casino group audit